Vegan Meatball Sub with Frozen Meatballs (Subway Copycat!)

Rich, saucy and irresistible is how I’d best describe this vegan meatball sub! It’s a must-make for anyone craving a nostalgic, take-out style classic made entirely plant-based. With perfectly seasoned frozen meatballs simmered in marinara and velvety, homemade vegan cheese sauce it comes together in under 30 minutes and no special skills required!

I’ve been vegan for over a decade now, and cooking long enough to know that the good food we cling to are rarely about the ingredients. They’re about the memories. This sub was pre-work ritual: yes that means I would take on a foot long sub from subway just minutes before starting my eight hour shit at the pizza shop.

Sloppy, loud, and unapologetically saucy. The kind of thing you eat with both hands and no regrets. rebuilding it in a fully vegan version was a personal challenge of mine, and a way to prove that the food that shaped us doesn’t have to be gone forever! After countless tests in the kitchen, this one hits the sweet spot where comfort an convenience shake hands.

Reliability, without the nonsense

What I love most about this version is how reliably it delivers. Frozen meatballs may not sound glamorous(and by all means follow along one of our recipes like these honey garlic meatballs if you want to make them from scratch), but they strip away the nonsense and get straight to the good part. A quick sear, a slow simmer in sauce and suddenly you’ve got a sandwich that looks and tastes like you care. Through development, a few choices proved non-negotiable for me.

• I found that frozen meatballs hold together better, so less falling apart in your hands like some vegan meatball recipes tend to.
• letting the meatballs, herbs and sauce simmer together rather than piling on afterward give amore cohesive, restaurant feel.
• Having trouble getting those cheese shreds to melt and look good? My experience has found whipping up the quickest cheese sauce makes all the difference!

Where the details start to shine

What surprised me most in the almost week straight of testing this recipe wasn’t the meatballs or sauce. Individually, these ingredients make this a very simple sandwich! It’s the way everything fits together that determines whether you get a balanced, satisfying bite. Or a sandwich just piled with ingredients fighting for your attention.

Pace the heat and moisture. I found that warming the sauce separately before mixing together, toasting the bun just before serving and assembling while everything is at its flavourful peak is what keeps the sub tasting intentional, rather than thrown together.

No shortcuts, do it right

At least that’s how I feel deep down when it comes to my passion for sandwich making. But follow these steps and I have no doubt you’ll be doing it right in no time! When I test a recipe, I’m always looking for ways to punch it up without it becoming a chore. For this sub, a few small tweaks make a huge difference.

• I found that toasting the roll is a necessary step to keep the bottom from turning into a soggy mess.
• Let the cheese sauce thicken enough, for the love of god. Nobody likes a sub where the cheese falls off instead of clings.
• Taste the marinara before adding the meatballs in. I think a pinch of sugar or dash of salt can save a lot of so-so jarred sauces.

In my extensive sandwich experience, these aren’t option tweaks. They’re what separate a lazy sandwich from one you’ll actually remember.

Print